EN BG

False Dilemma

"You're either with us or against us." Funny how there are only ever two options, and one of them makes you the enemy.

A false dilemma is when someone frames a situation as having only two choices when there are actually many more. Left or right. Pro-science or anti-science. With the government or with the terrorists. Support the war or hate your country. The binary is clean, simple, and almost always a lie. Reality rarely splits into exactly two camps — but forcing people to pick a side is one of the oldest moves in persuasion.

The power of the false dilemma is that it kills nuance before the conversation even starts. The moment you accept the frame of "A or B," every position between, beyond, or outside those two options disappears. You can't say "I support the goal but disagree with the method." You can't say "both sides have a point but both are also missing something." Those positions don't fit the binary, so they don't exist.

Politicians love this. Media loves this. Anyone trying to build a loyal base loves this — because nothing bonds a group faster than a shared enemy. And you can't have an enemy without a clear "us vs. them." If you want to understand how the political spectrum traps your thinking, start here. The two-sided frame is where it begins.

References